Primary Fermenters

General homebrewing talk that doesn't fall specifically within the categories below.
Post Reply
bargoon
Posts: 13
Joined: 1 year ago
Favourite Beer: Chestnut Ale

Primary Fermenters

Post by bargoon » 1 year ago

I see some people primary fermenting in a plastic brew bucket and others using a carboy. Besides ease of cleaning, is one better than the other?

Mr_Tastyfish
Posts: 425
Joined: 5 years ago
Favourite Beer: Homebrewed beer
Location: Orleans, ON

Re: Primary Fermenters

Post by Mr_Tastyfish » 1 year ago

Plastic buckets work fine, but are prone to staining and can hold onto smells (though this doesn't seem to normally affect the flavour from one beer to the next). Plastic is also much easier to scratch during regular cleaning, and these scratch marks can potentially harbour bacteria that could infect a batch of wort. Using glass carboys eliminates these issues. They really aren't that difficult to clean, but breaking one has sent more than one brewer to the hospital for stitches. There are of course, other options like the Better Bottle or Fermonster (both made of PET plastic) or more expensive stainless steel fermenters. Which is "better" all depends on what qualities you really desire in a fermenter.

User avatar
brhenrio
Moderator
Posts: 434
Joined: 3 years ago
Favourite Beer: Stouts
Location: Bonnyville, Ab

Re: Primary Fermenters

Post by brhenrio » 1 year ago

Mr_Tastyfish wrote:Plastic buckets work fine, but are prone to staining and can hold onto smells (though this doesn't seem to normally affect the flavour from one beer to the next). Plastic is also much easier to scratch during regular cleaning, and these scratch marks can potentially harbour bacteria that could infect a batch of wort. Using glass carboys eliminates these issues. They really aren't that difficult to clean, but breaking one has sent more than one brewer to the hospital for stitches. There are of course, other options like the Better Bottle or Fermonster (both made of PET plastic) or more expensive stainless steel fermenters. Which is "better" all depends on what qualities you really desire in a fermenter.
What mr tastyfish said. I have gone through carboys buckets and am now using ss brew bucket. Carboys can be a pia to clean and i almost sent myself to the hospital breaking one, and i have had a bad batch out of a plastic bucket that seemed to affect the next batch as well.
In the fermentor: Cherry Brown Sour, Raspberry Sour, Golden Sour, Gentleman's Skids Brown Ale
Tap 1: Root Beer
Tap 2: Destined for the drain
Tap 3: Lil' Runt Mild
Tap 4: Kicked

User avatar
Reignman
Posts: 1718
Joined: 7 years ago
Favourite Beer: Pilsners
Location: Cavan, Ont.

Re: Primary Fermenters

Post by Reignman » 1 year ago

I have 2 plastic carboys. I use oxiclean to clean them ( soaked overnight ) and it seems to work fine. No more glass for me after nicking an artery a couple of years ago. Very light and easy to move around.

User avatar
Warthaug
Posts: 802
Joined: 7 years ago
Favourite Beer: The wet kind
Location: SW Ontario
Contact:

Re: Primary Fermenters

Post by Warthaug » 1 year ago

I use plastic buckets and carboys, depending on the beer being brewed. Plasitc is great for fast turn-around beers, or anything you want to open-ferment, but as others have stated already you need to take care with your cleaning to avoid scratching it. My current bucket is 6 years old, about 50 brews in, and I've not had any issues with flavour/aroma transferring from one beer to the next. I do not brew sours (with the exception of kettle sours which are boiled after souring) in my plastic fermenters.

I use glass carboys for any beer requiring more than a few weeks in primary (big beers), or which needs protection from oxygen (IPAs), or which has souring bugs in it. Down side is that they can be dangerous if broken, so take care!

Bryan
Visit my blog at suigenerisbrewing.com. Homebrewing, yeast wrangling, wild yeast and more!

User avatar
ECH
Posts: 318
Joined: 4 years ago
Favourite Beer: IPA
Location: Hanwell, New Brunswick (just outside of Fredericton)
Contact:

Re: Primary Fermenters

Post by ECH » 1 year ago

I use a Fast Ferment for all of my fermentation needs unless I am doing a Lager/Pils, which needs to go in the fridge (FF is too big for the fridge), or if I am doing something with a Brett or Lacto yeast, in which you don't want to use plastic for.

As far as cleaning, I fill it up with hot water and oxyclean, and let it sit for a day. Rinse with hot water, and viola. The plastic of the FF will take on a smell, mostly from dry hops I have used in it, but it hasn't affected any of the brews I have put through it.

User avatar
bellybuster
Posts: 652
Joined: 4 years ago
Favourite Beer: stout
Contact:

Re: Primary Fermenters

Post by bellybuster » 11 months ago

Speidel

hawkbox
Posts: 62
Joined: 2 years ago
Location: AB

Re: Primary Fermenters

Post by hawkbox » 10 months ago

I've got a couple plastic 50L buckets, a couple PET carboys, 1 Fermonster, and a bunch of glass carboys I don't use and my wife uses for wine. I like the Fermonster and PET carboys mostly because then I can watch the action. For simplicity the buckets are a win.

I'd love a stainless steel one but they're 10X the price of a Fermonster so hard to justify.

Post Reply